Can someone please tell me why whenever anyone seems to come back McShane gets dropped?
Even though we seem to be short of out and out hookers especially when Burrow is at half back.
I don't pretend to be an expert but when I watch the home matches he always does ok or a good job?
What is the reason McDermott keeps dropping him?
Worst case scenario I could see him leaving Leeds!!!!

IF Mcshane is dropped for last weeks performance its deserved imo but that subject gets messy when you consider the other players who have stinkers and don't get dropped!!

He had a poor match last week, hence why he's being dropped. We can afford to do it as Sinfield is back.

I personally don't think he's good enough to be our number 9 but as discussed in countless other threads, opinion seems to be split on this one.

He didn't have the best of games last Friday night unfortunately. Which has resulted in him being farmed out to Hunslet this weekend.

Its very frustrating that we have an out and out hooker in McShane yet he never seems to get a good enough run of games to establish himself. Burrow starting at hooker does not work for me. If Sinfield is back, then he goes to 6, Burrow should stay at 7 and we need to leave McShane at 9 and see what he can do.

You can see the logic in sending the likes of Vickery...Achurch etc to learn some trade at Hunslet. Not sure what Macca will take from it.

But Bri Mac's line of 'its important Macca plays this weekend' is just cringworthy.

McShane is early in his career and has no pedigree. I don't believe you give all players the same leeway, some have earned a stinker every now and then. Simple solution for McShane is to not give the coach a reason to drop him.

McShane's been sniffing around the first team since 2008 and made his first team debut in 2009. Although I agree with you in that he should be playing well enough to earn his spot, I don't think we should consider him as a fledgling player any more.

No it's not. McShane needs to play to improve his fitness because as yet he is not capable of a full 80 minutes. Not only did he have a greedy stinker last time out but he tends to go missing in games. Perhaps his problem is Mrs Miggins's pie shop?

Yet if it was Kirke JC you'd have a spreadsheet of his stats and be defending him to the hilt would you not??

He can work internally on his fitness, IF that's what the issue is. I don't see how playing for Hunslet at a level where you drop intensity and velocity is vital this week. I'd keep him in and around the team as much as possible (unless there's issues we don't know about).

How many hookers play 80 minutes in Super League?

Burrow



Your point is valid....McShane AND Hood rotated from the bench would have been a best from we have got situation (and well established already this season with a 'decent' coach)

Kirke was equally as bad as McShane last week, even allowing for unjury. No crappy spreadsheets can hide that.